Duncan Idaho's Compendium of Comprehensive Offseason Plans

[Couch-Potato]

Originally Posted by Nightfyre

Given the subjective characteristics of PFF's evaluation, does aggregating this stuff (I won't even call it data) mean anything? Like if Aaron Donald's evaluator has even a little bias, it would just be amplified in the aggregation, for example. Unless there are strictly objective criteria or some measure of control over such "metrics" (which again, I think is objectively a stretch of the capability of the PFF evaluation system) isn't this chart worth as much as any given eye test?

Lots of penalties are objective as well, but we accept that.

I'm a PFF fan, but understand most aren't.