Quote:
Originally Posted by Detoxing
Ya'll are doing in this thread what the "experts" do when evaluating college talent: Judging the player by the team instead of the player himself.
|
In college you can have a great/elite QB and have a completely mediocre team, but how often does that same scenario happen in the NFL? How often do great QBs lead their NFL teams to a 3-4 win season? Hell even average to slightly above average QBs can win their team a handful of games.
Look at Matt Ryan, I'd put him in that great QB column and hes had a one 4 win season and one 6 win season in 13 years.
Matt Stafford since becoming the full time starter has only one 4 win season and one 6 win season.
Ryan Tannehill lowest win total was 6 while he was with the trash Dolphins and had to play the Patriots 2 times a season. He won 7 games or more in every other season with them.
Kirk Cousins started 3 seasons for the shit hole Washington Redskins and won 9, 8, and 7 games in those seasons he started.
Matt Schaub while with the Texans
07 4-7
08 6-5
09 9-7
10 6-10
11 7-3
12 12-4
13 2-6
In the NFL all you need is an average QB to not be completely terrible. Watson is on pace for 2 wins this season, but some of you wanna act like he's some great QB that's being held back by everyone. Great QBs don't have 2 win seasons no matter how bad the coaching or team is.