Quote:
Originally Posted by dlphg9
But why can't you debate the greatest WR/RB? Ive seen it done. They just did that NFL 100, that was a debate of who was the best at all positions.
When were talking about best player in the NFL why can't it be a QB? I would say that the best player would be the person with the greatest impact during a game and that would be Mahomes. Any team in the league would take Mahomes over their current situation. I can't say that about any other player at any other position.
I think what youre thinking best=most athletic, but the NFL is literally filled with world class athletes and most of those guys fail.
|
So who can we debate vs Jerry Rice and Jim Brown, curious to see that. Technically Brown was a FB but that gets ignored.
I will say this, there is a realistic debate about Don Hutson vs Jerry Rice, NOBODY ever dominated their position like Don Hutson did. He was catching more passes in a season than the next 4/5 cats combined.
No ball carrier compares to Jim Brown, his was ALL PRO 8 times in his 9 season career, a 9 time pro bowler. STILL the only ball carrier to average 100 yards a game for a career.