Quote:
Originally Posted by DJ's left nut
If Deshaun Watson were more athletic, he'd be Caleb Williams.
Watson created far more headaches for himself than he needed to and in the end the only thing he truly did well was throw a pretty deep ball.
Clay would've masturbated furiously to either of those guys back in 2015 in his 'throw it deeeeeeeep' days.
Williams has tools, no question. Premier arm talent, great athleticism. But he's not a polished quarterback in a lot of ways. We've gotten a little bit nutty in that we suddenly expect these guys to be finished products when very very few truly are. He could absolutely learn how to do most of these things he struggles with.
But Fields never did. Many guys before that didn't. And Williams has to self-scout in order to make those improvements; it's not a given that he's open to that sort of thing.
I'd take him at 1.1. I'd simply not be willing to pass on the tools. But man - there's a lot more risk here than many want to think.
|
To me there are two guys at the top in Caleb and Drake.
Both have talent to be very good. For most prospects, unless you are a generational player like Mahomes or a horrible prospect like Josh Rosen, the destination matters a lot.
If you are a talented prospect and go to a team with no oline, weapons or coaching you are going to look bad.
Then you need coaching fit.
If Josh Allen went to Shanahan I don't think he would be what he is now. He got Daboll who built a unique offense around the QB. Not every QB drafted gets that opportunity.