Kyler Murray vs Garner Minshew
 

Try....Gardner

This from last season.

Murray

Comp %...69.0
yards...4361
TD/INT...42-7

Minshew

70.7
4779
38-9

I can see a situation similiar to Bledsoe/Brady, Romo/Prescott here. I saw 6/7 WSU games last season, trust me Minshew can play. I have no problems seeing him taking Foles job away, just think Matt Flynn/Russell Wilson.

I also see him out playing Murray.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhRFWO6Mfb0

He actually looked pretty decent out there

Yes, the guy can play.

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb...8-leaders.html

In a few weeks...."who is this Gardner Minshew?"

ok

yeah, I was watching the game and thought maybe it was better for them that Foles got hurt. They might have found something. It's one game but he definitely didn't look like a rookie. Looked poised and confident and made some solid decisions.

Yeah I’m a fan of this dude. He made good decisions throughout the game last week and he has a solid personality. I’m rooting for him.

Nick Foles has won a superbowl. He also holds the record for most TDs thrown in a game. He also has a season where he had the 3rd highest QB rating ever.

Nick Foles is the mother ****in man.

I get this is just JC but.....

Minshew began his college football career in 2015 at Northwest Mississippi Community College. He led the team to the NJCAA National Football Championship, passing for 3,228 yards with a 60.8% completion percentage.

When it comes to the NCAA I'm a USC fan, but do watch a lot of Pac12 football. I was actually blown away watching this guy at WSU, yep....poised and confident, and solid decision making.

I see big things for this guy.

Gardner Minshew ****ing sucks.

He was playing against Charvarious Ward and Bashaud Breeland.

He is garbage on the scrap heap.

He definitely looks like a guy that is going to be on an NFL roster for 10 years and possibly a starter.

He swings the biggest dick - but is also the biggest broke dick sometimes. Dick.

As soon as he came in I said "This is Todd Bouman all over again." Sure as shit.

Maybe he can be Mahomes backup next season.

Why are you talking about Breeland like he isn’t a good player?

There is a blues cat that goes with...WillieB

Anyway....

Let's try this my man....

In his rookie season Nick Foles started 6 games and put up these numbers.

Comp% 60.9
Yards 1699
TD/INT 6/5

I have no doubts of any kind that Minshew does far better than that AND...out plays Murray.

Did he get to play the Chiefs secondary all year?

No.

He did not.

Gardner Minshew is garb.

You'll see.

Below avg corner who is our best outside corner. This is not good.

What a stupid ****ing take.

Breeland is above average and he played very well on Sunday. I swear the majority of CP has no clue about the rest of the NFL.

Dude, why not just admit you don't know a damn thing about this guy, ok? Why toss obvious bullshit around?

This from those who make a living knowing players.....


STRENGTHS

—Fiery, passionate leader who took the long way to Washington State after starting his career at Northwest Mississippi Community College and then signing at East Carolina, where he was a backup for two seasons.

—Went from a forgotten graduate transfer to Pac-12 Offensive Player of the Year; loved by teammates and coaches for his fiery leadership and charisma. One scout called him "a Baker Mayfield-like dude."

—Accurate passer on underneath and timing routes; throws with good awareness and doesn't make his receivers reach for the ball.

—Has enough athleticism to make plays on the move; will scramble and can be effective on rollouts. Incredibly tough and isn't afraid to take a shot to make a play.

Want more?

Ayy he isn't horrible, but he's our #1 outside corner. This is not a good situation to be in.

Pac 12 quarterbacks at bottom feeder schools. Who we are over valuing because he posts reasonable stats against one of the worst defenses in the league.

Pump the brakes on GARDNER MINSHEW.

Please stop talking about any players on my garbage team. Yall destroyed us, it's over. LEt me mourn my organization in peace.

I mean i've seen so many guys that can play in college and you think it will translate to the NFL and it doesn't. Not saying Minshew can't play or make it, but its absolutely wild the level in which you have to be at to be a "good" NFL quarterback

Aaron Rodgers also went the JC route before landing at Cal. looking at his senior season vs Minshew....Minshew.

Foles was out of Arizona, he was also inferior.

Look at all these stud Pac12 QB's,

Dan Fouts
Drew Bledsoe
Mark Brunell
John Elway
John Brodie
Andrew Luck
Warren Moon
Troy Aikman
Aaron Rodgers
Carson Palmer

Now compare what any of them did in that senior season vs Minshew.

Check out both John Elway and Andrew Luck's senior seasons vs Minshew.

What amazes me is guys like Kurt Warner, Tony Romo, who made no impact on NFL scouts at all, then to do what they did.

Minshew was a hype machine in college

People were sporting mustaches

I won’t be surprised if he has more wins than scam newton by end of the season ROFL

Minshew will be legit.

I think those outside the west coast/PAC12 really aren't too familiar with this guy, I do expect that to change.

Comparing senior seasons

Sam Darnold

comp%...63.1
yards....4143
TD/INT...26/12
Passer rating...148.1

Josh Rosen

62.6
3456
26/10
147.0

Gardner Minshew

70.7
4779
38/9
147.6

All Minshew.

we have a tradition of facing a QB that's never played before and kicking off their career by making them look good. Then they get a starting job and suck.

The way I judge a rookie QB is very simple. Does he look nervous? Is he making plays downfield? Is he accurate? I'd say he did very well in all of these areas. I certainly didn't expect as much poise out of him as he showed.

I don't know if he'll be a starter in this league, but he certainly has a future as a
GOOD backup in this league, which he already is.

Yeah but which one is black and can hand off to a white RB?

I think you pretty much nailed it. Decision making and protecting the ball for a young guy very important.

I saw Rodgers at Cal, Luck at Stanford, Darnold/Rosen, they had nothing on Minshew at the NCAA level.

Little man, did you really post this stupidity?

Internet jukeboxes
**** em. And **** the Bosniaks that play 20 ****ing minute long techno songs.

Which got....0...replies.

Dude, grow the **** up, ok guy?

If Mindhew fails it looks to me like his arm won’t be good enough or he won’t stay healthy. Or of course coaching can ruin him.

It looked like he had it between the ears last week.

Minshew is 2 foot taller.

Incredibly healthy brain

Or why not the more obvious Baker Mayfield comps.

Cooper Barrett has a race preoccupation.

BWillie is wrong a lot, so you may be right.

Yup.

Did you guys know that one of these QBs is black, and one of them is white?

*waits for this dweeb to search my thread history to find one with a small number of replies, with his trademark punchline "ok guy?" at the end*

Remember when you made a drunk thread 8 years ago, dumbshit? You’re one to talk, okay guy?

I don’t even know who this Cooper guy is, but can he google random track statistics like I can?

should change the title to MINSHAW vs Mahomes :

2019:
Gardner Minshew
88%.... 275 yrds.... 11 yrds per throw..... 2 TDS


Mahomes:
75.8% 378yrds 11.5 per throw 3TDS

https://chumley.barstoolsports.com/w...M-1024x731.png

Kyler Murray looks like a homunculus.
For that reason, Garden Cashew gets my vote.

There is no doubt about his arm, none.

The next Kyler Murray?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdxeCAqSeIs

The next Christian McCaffery

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpuK2YciocI

It's too early in the season to get excited about any of these guys. I have heard everyone sucking off Minshew and Lamar Jackson this week and it's driving me nuts. Does anyone not remember how awesome RGIII looked in his first few starts? Or how about Fitz"magic" last year? Yeah, Mahomes came out hot last year and turned out to be for real, but that doesn't mean that Jackson and Minshew will be. Maybe they will. But I seriously doubt it(especially witb Jackson). It's funny how all of the media kept saying that Mahomes wasn't going to be able to keep doing what he was doing just last year, yet now everyone is swinging on the jocks of these guys after 1 good game.

Sucking off? Come on man.

Ron Dayne was a monster at Wisconsin he dragged wanna tacklers to a Heisman trophy. In the NFL.....bust!

Clem Daneils was a converted cornerback out of Prairie View...and...the first 1000 yard rusher for the Raiders.

So we obviously never know what will happen down the road, but........what we do is Minshew was actually "great" at WSU and the first time we see him in the NFL he completes how many in a row, and looked good doing it.

Will he be the next Aaron Rodgers.....nope! But can he start in the NFL...???

I didn't know this until now.

Minshew had the highest comp% by a rookie in his first game in NFL..........history.

He played with a lot of poise, showed toughness and accuracy. It appears his mental clock is fast. These are attributes that good NFL QB's have. Will he be a good NFL QB? Too early to tell, but he's got material to work with.

In preseason his mental clock was slow as molasses. It seems the game has slowed down for him. But I'm not holding my breath.

Jags won't win a game until week 8 vs the Jets.

Evaluating a QB's talent after facing a Chiefs defense?

That's just dumb.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EEdgkW0X...jpg&name=large

Vs

https://cdn-s3.si.com/styles/marquee...?itok=B6BpWDVp

I picked him up in my fantasy league.

Minshew must of gotten better real quick. In the preseason Foles didn't play, I watched the game against the Ravens. Minshew played almost the whole game. Final score Ravens 29, Jags 0 Mishew 7 of 14 for 46 yards, he didn't impress too many. Of course it's hard to play good when you're under constant pressure.

https://amp.businessinsider.com/imag...04-750-375.jpg

He did nothing today to change my mind about him having NFL talent.

We'll get a real good look Thursday night, not that a rookie season is the all everything, just ask Goff, and a ton of others.

Tonight is the night the world meets Gardner Minshew. All he did in his first two games was have the highest passer rating in a rookies first two games since way way back in the day.

~~~~~~~~~~~

While here....

I knew Lamar Jackson ran some HS track, and when I found he had a 11.4 100m PR I thought I had the wrong Lamar Jackson, HS girls can run faster than that. I ran faster than that (10.65)

Why?

You never know until they get a chance.

You're kidding, right?

On the internet it always goes like this....

If you brag about somebody and they shine, it's......crickets.

If they totally suck it's......hahahaha!....boy you sure can pick um....anymore insight?

Let's see what happens tonight.

But you were being chased by the cops.

Actually I was being chased by Ocie Early and Milton Edwards at the league meet. Also won the long jump with a PR 22-10.

Wasn’t he on our team for a little while?

If Minshew keeps playing like he has so far, hmmmm?

Yes and I was a proponent for starting him back then over Alex Smiff. People disagreed. A Super Bowl ensued for him later.

If he had some legit receivers,....sheesh~~~

Did you watch the game tonight?

What?

Tacks got an ass Minchewing.

FAX

**** his mustache

translation

Ok ok ok, I was wrong about the guy, ok?

Im willing to admit maybe and that I understimated Spags defense. I just have very little faith in the KC Chiefs defense without a pass rush...which we just got rid of

Ok, cool!

You do know there have been TONS of NFL QB's with mustaches/beards, right?

KEEP ****ING DOUBTING UNCLE RICO

He's got the power of the 'stache

All these QB's has a stache sometime in the career.

Aaron Rodgers
Joe Flacco
Ken Anderson
Joe Namath
Jeff George
Marcus Mariota
Mark Sanchez
Jake Plummer
Jeff Hostellier
Baker Mayfield
Carson Palmer

and if I did some digging plenty more.

I cannot believe that you left out a black QB that had a mustache

<blockquote class="imgur-embed-pub" lang="en" data-id="a/X7z31Cx" data-context="false" ><a href="//imgur.com/a/X7z31Cx"></a></blockquote><script async src="//s.imgur.com/min/embed.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

I just mixed a tape for my truck, it has a tape deck.

Bob Wills and His Texas Playboys
Dock Boggs
Dick Justice
The Carter Family
Jimmie Rodgers
Clarence Ashley....original "House of the Rising Sun" 1933 (original King Kong)
Frank Hutchison
Darby & Tarlton
Roy Acuff
Ernest Tubb
Milton Brown
Jimmie Davis....governor of Louisiana
The Skillet Lickers

Love that stuff, can't stand rap.....go figure!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxkSuBhzHqg