Eh. It could work assuming it's not a full blown musical. If the movie is mostly about his descent into madness with sprinkles of music mixed in to express his descent, it has potential to be good.

It still really chaps my ass this Joker is apparently self contained.

Looks good. I like Lady Gaga as an actress.

Eh....I don't know.

She really can act. It's got good people in it. Man, I absolutely adored the first one. Just that perfect balance of honoring the old while exploring the new. Told its story honestly enough to ruffle feathers and make people uncomfortable on all sides.

I don't know if I actually see something that worries me or I just have so much respect for the original that I'm worried they'll **** this up.

Jesus. I really hated the first Joker movie. Just so much over-acting, people trying to win awards, too over the top dark and violent, just not a fun movie at all. I nearly walked out of the theater on that one, and I never do that. I’m going to skip this one.

**** that.

Musicals ****ing suck.

****ing awful

I thought there was no way Gaga would pull that off but she killed it. Great performance. Hopefully, they will land this one too.

I really liked Moulin Rouge. It can be done.

Angry white males who wear cargo shorts love the joker......

I know lets make it a musical

100% factual statement...

I'm here for it. Like the world needs another Marvel movie.

I like when studios take risks.

Mostly.

I like The Wall by Pink Floyd and the 0G Willie Wonka. That's the only musicals I've ever enjoyed...

South park musical was good

Are you talking about bigger longer and uncut or the book of Mormon. Because both of those are awesome.