Andrew Luck Retires

[Bump]

Originally Posted by mr. tegu

Is there anything else even comparable? Is Barry Sanders the closest thing?

Calvin Johnson.

But I don't think they retired during week 3 in the preseason.

I was a little salty when Roaf retired right before preseason that one year.

[Why Not?]

Originally Posted by mr. tegu

Is there anything else even comparable? Is Barry Sanders the closest thing?

Still not comparable. A good starting QB in the NFL walking away in his prime(age wise)is simply not a thing that happens.

[Baby Lee]

Originally Posted by Why Not?

Still not comparable. A good starting QB in the NFL walking away in his prime(age wise)is simply not a thing that happens.

Not the same circumstances, but it almost has a feel of a Scott Norwood situation.

Too much mental trauma to compete, even if healthy.