Who would you rather have on the roster - Toney or Moore?

[TwistedChief]

Originally Posted by Gary Cooper

Why?

After Toney's bizarre tweet last year, I expected him to do something crazy, like "Antonio Brown crazy". Don't need a bad locker room distraction.

Moore seems like a good dude who just belongs in the CFL.

Our floor is defined and perfectly acceptable given the offseason additions.

Moore’s ceiling is nowhere. Toney has shown he can really flash and with the space he’ll have to work with given Brown/Worthy, there’s plenty of reason to think he can feast underneath without feeling the pressure of being a top option.

If Toney flames out, you cut him. Game over. Much rather give him that shot than go with Moore who isn’t going anywhere.

[Gary Cooper]

Originally Posted by TwistedChief

Our floor is defined and perfectly acceptable given the offseason additions.

Moore’s ceiling is nowhere. Toney has shown he can really flash and with the space he’ll have to work with given Brown/Worthy, there’s plenty of reason to think he can feast underneath without feeling the pressure of being a top option.

If Toney flames out, you cut him. Game over. Much rather give him that shot than go with Moore who isn’t going anywhere.

Outside of the Jaguars game in the regular season in 2022, and one great punt return in the Super Bowl that year, when has he shown "flashes"?

[TwistedChief]

Originally Posted by Gary Cooper

Outside of the Jaguars game in the regular season in 2022, and one great punt return in the Super Bowl that year, when has he shown "flashes"?

You ever watch his game against Dallas in his rookie season?

You ever see the way he moves in general?

Compare that to Skyy Moore. His best play in the NFL to date was on a broken coverage against the Jaguars.

[Rausch]

Originally Posted by TwistedChief

You ever watch his game against Dallas in his rookie season?

You ever see the way he moves in general?

Compare that to Skyy Moore. His best play in the NFL to date was on a broken coverage against the Jaguars.

I hear he's a great guy but from a football perspective Sky brings absolutely nothing to the table. Nothing.

[PatMahomesIsGod]

Originally Posted by TwistedChief

You ever watch his game against Dallas in his rookie season?

You ever see the way he moves in general?

Compare that to Skyy Moore. His best play in the NFL to date was on a broken coverage against the Jaguars.

Best play was Corn Dog 2 in the SB.

But yeah, he blows goats.

[Gary Cooper]

Originally Posted by TwistedChief

You ever watch his game against Dallas in his rookie season?

You ever see the way he moves in general?

Compare that to Skyy Moore. His best play in the NFL to date was on a broken coverage against the Jaguars.

No, I never watched his game from three years ago when he was playing for a different team. I understand that he has more career highlights than Skyy Moore. I would hope so for his sake.

Both guys should get a chance in training camp but if they don't produce the team should feel comfortable to part ways with either player.

They helped us win the SB in 2022 but their absence helped us win the SB in 2023.

I'm still picking Moore because he's less of a locker room distraction but I can't justify keeping Moore either. He needs to contribute to have a roster spot.

If the poll had the option of "Neither" we'd all probably click it.