Would you trade....

[chop]

I have been offered CMC and G. Pickens for J. Taylor and whatever bottom player I have on my roster. Would you do it?

[kccrow]

keeper or non-keeper?

[chop]

Originally Posted by kccrow

keeper or non-keeper?

No keepers

[tyecopeland]

I would if the difference between Pickens and whatever bottom feeder is at least somewhat significant. Jt and cmc are very comparable. The one just comes with more injury risk, but I'll say he'll have the better season.

[chop]

The bottom of the lineup is Isaiah Spiller, Joshua Kelley, and Isaiah Likely. So I would give up one of these three.

[The Franchise]

PPR? If so then I would. Taylor is due for a regression and they’ve already said that they aren’t going to ride him as much as they did last year.

[chop]

1/2 ppr

[CatfishBob2]

I wouldnt take a trade that im offered if i felt like i was taking the most risk. You are in this deal... A hyped up rookie isn't enough to sweeten the deal for me. You might as well drop those Chargers though

[kccrow]

After having CMC in two leagues back-to-back years headed into this one, I'm scared off to some extent (although I got him on auto draft again lol). That said, CMC is the best player in the league if he can stay healthy. Depends on how risk-averse you are. If so, take the trade.

[Why Not?]

You want 17 games of a slightly less used Taylor, or 6 (if that) games of a worked to death McCaffrey? Answer that question and you'll know what to do.

[kccrow]

So... had a trade offer in a non-PPR, 10-team league of Tee Higgins for Javonte Williams and I said no but countered with Clyde Edwards-Helaire instead. He's now countered by offering me DJ Moore for Clyde and I accepted. I feel like I'm plenty strong at RB. I feel like Moore is the better WR, so not sure why he's attached to Higgins. Still, if Clyde produces around rookie form they are near equals. Good decision or bad?


Roster now:

QB Lamar Jackson
RB Derrick Henry
RB Leonard Fournette
RB Javonte Williams
RB Rhamondre Stevenson
RB Chase Edmonds
RB Tyler Allgeier
WR Keenan Allen
WR Terry McLaurin
WR DJ Moore
WR Amari Cooper
WR Jerry Jeudy
TE Cole Kmet
TE David Njoku
K Matt Prater
D/ST Miami Dolphins

[chop]

Originally Posted by kccrow

So... had a trade offer in a non-PPR, 10-team league of Tee Higgins for Javonte Williams and I said no but countered with Clyde Edwards-Helaire instead. He's now countered by offering me DJ Moore for Clyde and I accepted. I feel like I'm plenty strong at RB. I feel like Moore is the better WR, so not sure why he's attached to Higgins. Still, if Clyde produces around rookie form they are near equals. Good decision or bad?


Roster now:

QB Lamar Jackson
RB Derrick Henry
RB Leonard Fournette
RB Javonte Williams
RB Rhamondre Stevenson
RB Chase Edmonds
RB Tyler Allgeier
WR Keenan Allen
WR Terry McLaurin
WR DJ Moore
WR Amari Cooper
WR Jerry Jeudy
TE Cole Kmet
TE David Njoku
K Matt Prater
D/ST Miami Dolphins

I would have made the trade also.

[Why Not?]

Originally Posted by kccrow

So... had a trade offer in a non-PPR, 10-team league of Tee Higgins for Javonte Williams and I said no but countered with Clyde Edwards-Helaire instead. He's now countered by offering me DJ Moore for Clyde and I accepted. I feel like I'm plenty strong at RB. I feel like Moore is the better WR, so not sure why he's attached to Higgins. Still, if Clyde produces around rookie form they are near equals. Good decision or bad?


Roster now:

QB Lamar Jackson
RB Derrick Henry
RB Leonard Fournette
RB Javonte Williams
RB Rhamondre Stevenson
RB Chase Edmonds
RB Tyler Allgeier
WR Keenan Allen
WR Terry McLaurin
WR DJ Moore
WR Amari Cooper
WR Jerry Jeudy
TE Cole Kmet
TE David Njoku
K Matt Prater
D/ST Miami Dolphins

Dude. You should be investigated for robbery. Moore is an at worst top of the 3rd round pick. You do that all day. Your team is stacked. I'm guessing it's a 10 team league? If your guys stay healthy, you cruise into the playoffs.

[kccrow]

Originally Posted by Why Not?

Dude. You should be investigated for robbery. Moore is an at worst top of the 3rd round pick. You do that all day. Your team is stacked. I'm guessing it's a 10 team league? If your guys stay healthy, you cruise into the playoffs.

Yeah, 10-team league. I definitely got pretty strong at WR for what I feel is a guy that could falter. CEH's ceiling feels like Moore's normal. I'm a bit weak at TE unless Njoku pops off, but I'm hoping it won't matter. The struggle might be choosing the right flex each week. Luckily, my bye week for Lamar isn't until week 10 so I have some time to let things play out injury-wise before I need to make a decision on a backup off the waivers. I'm not used to being in 10-team leagues, and took a looooong time away from it, so it's a bit more difficult for me to gauge what amount of talent is subpar because every team feels loaded.

[DJ's left nut]

Originally Posted by kccrow

So... had a trade offer in a non-PPR, 10-team league of Tee Higgins for Javonte Williams and I said no but countered with Clyde Edwards-Helaire instead. He's now countered by offering me DJ Moore for Clyde and I accepted. I feel like I'm plenty strong at RB. I feel like Moore is the better WR, so not sure why he's attached to Higgins. Still, if Clyde produces around rookie form they are near equals. Good decision or bad?


Roster now:

QB Lamar Jackson
RB Derrick Henry
RB Leonard Fournette
RB Javonte Williams
RB Rhamondre Stevenson
RB Chase Edmonds
RB Tyler Allgeier
WR Keenan Allen
WR Terry McLaurin
WR DJ Moore
WR Amari Cooper
WR Jerry Jeudy
TE Cole Kmet
TE David Njoku
K Matt Prater
D/ST Miami Dolphins

I end up with DJ Moore in about every league I'm in. He's always sitting there at the back of 3, top of 4 as a WR2.

Does anybody actually watch football? That guy is a metronome, regardless of if his QB sucks. He's good for 75-80 catches and 1,100 yards every season like clockwork. If he's healthy, he's one of the few set and forget options you can get outside of the 2nd round (and he's been healthy his whole career).

Am I missing something? Why is this guy routinely getting drafted in the late 30s, early 40s?