Quote:
Originally Posted by Mecca
It goes to show that sometimes people get jobs they shouldn't have. I would argue most of the guys that work on radio know far less than people posting here yet the radio station wouldn't give us a second look.
|
It's fascinating to listen to former coaches when they get on these shows and recognize exactly how informed they are.
Belichick and Saban just killed it, for example. Their depth of knowledge is SO far beyond ours.
But I'd imagine even a guy like Staley, who looked like a complete nitwit most days, would just wipe the floor with us. I talked about Bob Sutton way back in the day and said that if he ever showed up on CP as a poster, he'd ****ing embarrass us. He'd absolutely massacre even the most knowledgeable amongst us.
And yeah, I'd guess that trickles down a bit. But I do wonder if college QBs would be quite enough. We might be getting there as college offenses get a little more complicated. But I don't think it used to be the case that many of those guys could come out and smoke us on the radio.
Maybe guys like Dorsey or Daniel - dudes who were really working through the game out there (and often ended up looking to coaching gigs at some point) but I don't think rank and file college QBs would really be next level.
I mean Ryan Leaf sometimes has some interesting insight but he also was in the NFL and did a little coaching as well.
Mostly I think you could take any swinging dick power 5 or above coordinator or HC and just make just about everyone else look silly.