If still relevant: Only ten players have won the Super Bowl and MVP in the same season, Bart Starr in 1966, Terry Bradshaw in 1978, Mark Moseley in 1982, Lawrence Taylor in 1986, Joe Montana in 1989, Emmitt Smith in 1993, Steve Young in 1994, Brett Favre in 1996 Terrell Davis in 1998 and Kurt Warner in 1999.

Did you read what you just wrote?? :shake:

forget these two guys...and give it to this man























https://media3.giphy.com/media/NaRgp...&rid=giphy.gif

Yes

The argument seems to be that Rodgers is more valuable to his team than Mahomes is to ours because even without Mahomes we would be a Strong playoff team.

That doesn’t mean that Mahomes isn’t a better player than Rodgers though.

I love Mahomes and I am completely ecstatic that we have a "generational" talent at QB. BUT.......

Last nights "announcers" completely missed a Rodgers no look pass, and possibly another. Hard to say about the second one because of camera angle. Given the entire season...SO FAR... Rodgers has my vote for MVP (a vote that means nothing!)

My thoughts exactly.

MVP- Most Valuable Player does not equal LBP-League Best Player.

Which player is most valuable??? A great QB on a great team? Or a great QB, carrying a mediocre team to the playoffs, on his back, by his incredible play alone?

MVP is a great accolade but it's a foot note. I just want Mahomes to get SB MVP! Super Bowl wins are forever!!!!

But it’s not his incredible play alone. Their defense did a great job last night against the Titans. They have blown out a bunch of teams this year because of the defense. He also has a great OL, a better receiver than anyone on the KC roster, better RB than anyone on KC roster. The OL/RB have taken a lot of stress off Rodgers this year. Lot of easy throws in the play action game.

Rodgers will get it because he has better stats. The surrounding talent is almost irrelevant

Quarterbacks carry “bad teams” to the playoffs every year. They don’t win MVP. The MVP goes to whatever QB is having the best overall season

Mahomes performance against New Orleans was as impressive QB play as you will see.

But the MVP award is heavily stat based and KC has taken its foot off the gas too often in the last few weeks.

Valid points. But better RB? Really? Not disputing, just questioning from lack of input/knowledge.

the last 7 weeks wins were by 1 possession...hard to believe this team is still 14-1.
Post Season will be an adventure.

Best overall season can be subjective....

I would put hill over Adams. Jones is better than we have right now. The o line is better in gb. Their defense is better but that's mostly just linebackers.

Winning the MVP vs. the Lombardi won't mean crap to Rogers.